Ikhadi le-IC vs Ikhadi Le-ID: Ungalikhetha Kanjani Ikhadi Lokufinyelela Elilungile Lohlelo Lwakho

Apr 23, 2026

Shiya umlayezo

Uma ngabe isakhiwo sakho sisasebenzisa amakhadi e-ID angu-125 kHz ukulawula ukufinyelela, nakhu okufanele ukwazi: idivayisi ephathwa ngesandla engaphansi kuka-$15 ingakwazi ukwenza ikhadi lakho ngaphansi kwamasekhondi angu-60. Lelo khadi elikhiqiziwe livula yonke iminyango elenziwa ekuqaleni. Kubaphathi bezikhungo abasanda kugunyaza i-oda lenqwaba lamakhadi omazisi ukuze bonge kuzindleko zeyunithi, ithegi yenani langempela livela kamuva, lapho lonke uhlelo sekufanele lukhishwe futhi lushintshwe.

Lesi sihloko sihlukanisa umehluko wangempela phakathi kwamakhadi e-IC namakhadi e-ID, hhayi nje inguqulo yeshidi elicacisiwe, kodwa umehluko othinta ngempela isinqumo sakho sokuthenga, ukuphepha kwesistimu yakho, kanye nenani lezindleko zakho zobunikazi.

 

Ikhadi le-IC nekhadi le-ID: Umehluko Oyinhloko kumasekhondi angu-30

Ikhadi le-ID

 

(125 kHz, isb, EM4100/TK4100): Igcina kuphela inombolo yesiriyeli engashintshi. Ikhadi lisakaza le nombolo kunoma yimuphi umfundi ebangeni. Akukho ukubethela, akukho khono lokubhala, akukho ukuxhawulana kobuqiniso. Umfundi umane ahlole ukuthi inombolo ihambisana yini nokufakwa kusizindalwazi.

Ikhadi le-IC

 

(13.56 MHz, isb, MIFARE Classic/DESFire): Iqukethe i-microprocessor chip enememori efundekayo nebhalekayo ehlukaniswe imikhakha ezimele. Isekela ukubethela, ukufakazela ubuqiniso phakathi kwekhadi nesifundi, kanye{4}}nokusetshenziswa okuningi kwezinhlelo zokusebenza ekhadini elilodwa.

Leyo yimpendulo yencwadi. Kodwa uma uhlola lezi ukuze uthole ukuthunyelwa kwangempela, incwadi ayikutsheli ukuthi yini engahambi kahle, noma ukuthi yini ebalulekile ngesabelomali sakho.

 

Security professional examining multiple RFID IC cards and ID cards for facility access control vulnerability testing

 

Izilinganiso Ezinhlanu Zokutholwa Kwempahla Ngeke Zikutshele

 

1

Ukuphepha Kwekhadi Lokufinyelela Akukona Okunambambili - Kuyi-Spectrum

 

Iphutha elivame kakhulu ekuthengeni ikhadi lokufinyelela: ukucabangela ukuthi "ikhadi le-IC=livikelekile, ikhadi le-ID=alivikelekile." Iqiniso libekwe ngaphezulu kwalokho.

 

Amakhadi omazisi anombhalo oyimfihlo onguziro. Noma yimuphi umfundi ongu-125 kHz, noma i-cloner ephathwa ngesandla engu-$15, ifunda futhi iphindaphinde inombolo ye-serial. Ayikho indlela yokuvimbela lokhu ezingeni lekhadi ngoba ikhadi alinayo indlela yokuqinisekisa.

 

Amakhadi e-IC avikeleke kakhulu, kodwa ukuthi okuningi kangakanani kuncike ngokuphelele ekutheni iyiphi i-chip oyikhethayo. I-MIFARE Classic, i-IC chip esakazwe kabanzi emhlabeni jikelele, isebenzisa isikimu sokubethela esibizwa nge-CRYPTO1 esahlehla ngokuphelele{2}}eyakhiwe abacwaningi base-Radboud University emuva ngo-2008. Namuhla, amathuluzi afana ne-Flipper Zero angakwazi ukubuyisela okhiye be-MIFARE Classic namakhadi e-clone ngaphandle kwezisetshenziswa ezikhethekile.

 

Ngo-Agasti 2024, isimo saba sibi kakhulu: Abacwaningi be-Quarkslab bathola i-backdoor yehadiwe kuma-chips e-Fudan FM11RF08S, i-chip esetshenziswa kakhulu ye-MIFARE Classic-evela e-Shanghai Fudan Microelectronics. Le backdoor ivumela noma ubani onolwazi lokhiye owodwa wendawo yonke ukuthi afake ebucayini bonke{5}}okhiye abachaziwe kulawa makhadi phakathi nemizuzu. Ama-chips athintekile asatshalaliswa emahhotela, emahhovisi, nasezinhlelweni zezokuthutha kulo lonke elase-US, Europe, China, kanye ne-India.

Kusho ukuthini lokhu ngesinqumo sakho sokuthenga:

Uma othile ekucaphuna "amakhadi e-IC" ngaphandle kokucacisa imodeli ye-chip nezinga layo lesitifiketi sokuphepha, awukutholi ukuthuthukiswa kokuvikeleka. Uthola ikhadi elibiza kakhulu okungenzeka libe sengozini. Izigaba zokuphepha zekhadi le-IC ziyi:

Izinga Lokuphepha Chip Izibonelo Ukubethela Ifanele
Lutho EM4100, TK4100 (ama-ID amakhadi) Lutho Ukupaka, izinga lokushisa lezivakashi liyadlula
Ifa (elifakwe engcupheni) I-MIFARE Classic 1K/4K I-CRYPTO1 (ephukile) Ukubamba -kwesikhathi sokuvikela okuphansi
Ileveli-ephakathi I-MIFARE Plus (imodi ye-SL3) I-AES-128 Ukufinyelela ehhovisi, amakhadi ekhampasi
Phezulu I-MIFARE DESFire EV2/EV3 (EAL5+ iqinisekisiwe) I-AES-128, i-mutual auth Izikhungo zedatha, izinsiza zezezimali
Okuphakeme kakhulu Amakhadi e-CPU (Ikhadi le-Java) I-PKI{0}iyakwazi Uhulumeni, wezempi

 

Umniningwane owodwa ithebula elingeke liwubonise: I-MIFARE Plus inamazinga okuphepha amathathu (SL1, SL2, SL3), kodwa izihlanganisi eziningi zisebenzisa amakhadi e-Plus ngemodi ye-SL1 ukuze ihambisane nemuva nabafundi be-Classic abakhona. Kumodi ye-SL1, ukuphepha kwekhadi empeleni kufana ne-MIFARE Classic evamile. Lesi yisimo esijwayelekile "se-spec sokuthuthukisa ephepheni, akukho ukuthuthukisa okwenziwayo". Njalo qinisekisa ukuthi iyiphi ileveli yokuphepha eyenziwe yasebenza, hhayi nje ukuthi iyiphi imodeli ye-chip ephrintiwe ekuqinisekisweni kwe-oda.

 

I-Syntek inikeza amakhadi okufinyelela kuzo zonke izigaba ezinhlanu ezibalwe ngenhla, kusukelaEM4100/TK4100 ID amakhadinge-MIFARE DESFire EV2/EV3 kanyeAmakhadi e-CPU-okulawula ukufinyelela kokuvikeleka okuphezulu. Lonke ikhadi le-IC lithunyelwa ngemodeli ye-chip ephrintiwe kunothi lokudiliva, ngoba ikhadi elingenayo i-chip spec ebhaliwe ikhadi ongeke uliqinisekise.

 

Advanced biometric and RFID IC card reader mounted on a modern glass door for high-security commercial office access

 

2

"Ikhadi Lishibhile" Libiza Kakhulu Esikhathini Esihambayo

 

Ku-$0.08–0.15 ngeyunithi ngayinye yamakhadi e-ID e-EM4100 uma kuqhathaniswa no-$0.30–0.60 we-MIFARE DESFire, ukonga{5}}kwekhadi ngalinye ku-oda lamakhadi angu-5,000{9}kubukeka kungokoqobo. Kodwa intengo yekhadi ngalinye ingumugqa owodwa kuphela eshidini lezindleko eziphelele.

 

Amasistimu ekhadi le-ID agcina idatha enguziro ekhadini ngokwalo. Zonke izinqumo zokufinyelela zidinga ukuthi umfundi abuze kusizindalwazi esimaphakathi ngesikhathi sangempela. Lokho kusho ukuthi wonke umfundi udinga uxhumano lwenethiwekhi (izintambo eziningi, amaphuzu okuhluleka), ukunwetshwa kwesistimu kusho ukufaka izintambo kubafundi abasha emuva kuseva, futhi akukho ukusebenza okungaxhunyiwe ku-inthanethi: uma inethiwekhi yehla, iminyango ihlala ikhiyiwe noma ngokuzenzakalelayo ukuze ivuleke.

 

Izinhlelo zekhadi le-IC zigcina izimvume ekhadini. Abafundi bangenza izinqumo zokufinyelela endaweni. Ukwandisa uhlelo kusho ukukhipha umfundi nokumisa imikhakha yamakhadi, akukho khebula entsha kuseva edingekayo.

 

Inkampani ephethe izakhiwo e-Shenzhen ithole lokhu ngemuva kokuba ucwaningo lwangaphakathi luveze ukuthi igaraji labo lokupaka likhipha amaphasi amaningi nyanga zonke kunalawo abhalwe phansi. Uphenyo lulandele igebe kubasebenzi abakopisha amakhadi omazisi angu-125 kHz besebenzisa amakhadi angenalutho avela eTaobao. Ngenxa yokuthi amakhadi ayengenakho ukubethela, kwakungekho umgoqo wobuchwepheshe: noma ubani one-cloner engu-$15 angakhiqiza ikhophi esebenzayo. Inkampani ilahle lonke uhlelo lwamakhadi kamazisi futhi{5}aphinde asetshenziswa ngamakhadi e-IC abethelwe, ekhokha kabili lokho obekumele kwenziwe kanye.

 

3

Uhlelo-Oluningi: Ikhadi Elilodwa, Amasistimu Amaningi

 

Imikhakha ezimele eziyishumi nesithupha. Yilokho okunikezwa ikhadi elijwayelekile le-MIFARE Classic 1K IC, futhi umkhakha ngamunye unganikeza uhlelo lokusebenza oluhlukile ngokhiye bawo bokubethela: ukulawula ukufinyelela kumkhakha 1, ukuba khona isikhathi kumkhakha 2, inkokhelo yendawo yokudlela emkhakheni wesi-3.

 

Amakhadi omazisi awakwazi ukwenza lokhu. Ikhadi elilodwa, inombolo ye-serial eyodwa, umsebenzi owodwa. Uma ufuna ukwengeza inkokhelo yendawo yokudlela ohlelweni lwakho lokufinyelela, ungakhipha ikhadi lesibili noma ushintshe yonke ingqalasizinda.

 

Okwakhelwe amapaki ekhampasi nezimboni lapho "{{0}ikhadi{1}}elilodwa{2}}lakho{2}}yonke into" kungumgomo, lokhu kukodwa kukhipha amakhadi e-ID angu-125 kHz. I-Syntek ikhiqiza amakhadi{2}}e-IC amaningi kanye namakhadi ayinhlanganisela-ahlanganisa ama-frequency ahlanganisa i-chip engu-125 kHz kanye ne-chip engu-13.56 MHz emzimbeni wekhadi elilodwa, okuphinde kube yindlela ukufuduka okunezigaba eziningi kusebenza ngayo.

 

Person using a smartphone NFC to unlock a secured office door, demonstrating the future-proofing benefits of 13.56MHz IC card technology

 

4

Kungani Umhlahlandlela Wakho Wokungena Kweselula Ulawula Amakhadi Omazisi

 

Ama-smartphones abasebenzi bakho asebenzisa i-NFC ku-13.56 MHz, okuyimvamisa efanayo namakhadi e-IC. Lokhu kusho ukuthi izifakazelo zekhadi le-IC zinganikezwa amafoni, okuvumela ukufinyelela kweselula okusekelwe ku-NFC{2}ngaphandle kwamakhadi aphathekayo.

 

Amakhadi omazisi angu-125 kHz awabonakali nhlobo ku-NFC hardware yocingo. Akukho ukulungisa okukhona. Uma imephu yomgwaqo yendawo yakho ihlanganisa ukufinyelela kweselula phakathi neminyaka emithathu kuya kwemihlanu ezayo, uhlelo lwekhadi le-ID engu-125 kHz luyisiphetho esingasebenzi. Ukuze uthole ukubuka okujulile kokuthi i-NFC isebenza kanjani ngaphakathi kokulawula ukufinyelela kwe-ecosystem, bona i-Syntek'sisingeniso kumasistimu okulawula ukufinyelela kwe-RFID.

 

5

Kungani Umhlahlandlela Wakho Wokungena Kweselula Ulawula Amakhadi Omazisi

 

Uma okwamanje usebenzisa isistimu yekhadi le-ID engu-125 kHz futhi izikhala zokuphepha ziyakukhathaza, ukushintshwa okugcwele kwesistimu akuyona ukuphela kwenketho. I-Dual-i-frequency readers ingaphatha womabili amakhadi angu-125 kHz no-13.56 MHz kanyekanye. Kuhlanganiswe namakhadi ayinhlanganisela-akabili (ikhadi elilodwa lishumeka kokubili i-ID ne-IC chip), ungathutha abasebenzisi ngezigaba: akukho ukunqamuka kosuku olulodwa{7}}, akukho ukuphazamiseka kwesevisi.

 

Ukuthi ukufuduka okukabili{0}}okukabili kuthatha isikhathi eside kangakanani kuncike enanini lezindawo zokufinyelela, izinga lenzuzo yesisebenzi, kanye nokuthi isofthiwe yakho yasemuva idinga ukubuyekezwa. Ibhilidi lehhovisi elinezicabha ezingu-20{4}lingase liphele ezinyangeni ezintathu. Ipaki-yezimboni eziningi enezisebenzi zangaphandle kanye nenzuzo ephezulu ingase ithathe isikhathi esingaphezu konyaka ukuze nje kuhoxiswe iqoqo lokugcina lamakhadi amadala. Intambo evamile ukuthi indlela ye-dual-frequency ikuvumela ukuthi usabalalise ukusetshenziswa kwemali enkulu kuyo yonke imijikelezo yakho yesabelomali esikhundleni sokuyithatha njengesamba sesamba esisodwa.

Lapho Omazisi Amakhadi Esezwakala

Akuzona zonke izimo ezidinga -ukuphepha kwezinga le-IC. Isihlungi sesinqumo esisheshayo:

 

Khetha amakhadi omazisi angu-125 kHz uma

uphethe izindawo zokupaka ezivulekile ezinezidingo zokuphepha eziphansi, ukufinyelela kwesivakashi kwesikhashana lapho amakhadi eqoqwa futhi aphinde akhishwe nsuku zonke (ingozi yokuhlanganisa incane ngoba umjikelezo wempilo wekhadi mfushane), noma isabelomali-i-retrofits evinjiwe lapho ingqalasizinda yomfundi engu-125 kHz futhi alukho uhlelo lokwengeza{2}}imisebenzi eminingi yohlelo lokusebenza.

 

Khetha amakhadi e-IC uma

noma yikuphi kwalokhu okulandelayo kuyasebenza: indawo yakho inezindawo lapho ukufinyelela okungagunyaziwe kudala khona isikweletu (ama-server, amalebhu, izitezi eziphezulu); udinga ikhadi elilodwa ukuze usebenze kukho konke ukulawula ukufinyelela, ukuya, kanye nenkokhelo; inqubomgomo yakho yezokuphepha idinga izindlela zokuhlolwa komnikazi wekhadi ngamunye; noma ulindele ukuthola ukufinyelela kwe-NFC yeselula phakathi neminyaka emithathu.

 

Uma izidingo zakho ziwela eqenjini lesibili, umbuzo olandelayo awukona okuthi "IC noma i-ID" kodwa "iyiphi i-IC chip tier efana nephrofayela yakho engcupheni." Bheka kuthebula lokuvikela elingenhla bese ulilethe engxoxweni yakho yomhlinzeki.

Ungakuqinisekisa Kanjani Lokho Okutholayo Empeleni

 

Ngaphambi kokufaka i-oda lekhadi lokufinyelela ngobuningi, qinisekisa izinto ezintathu nomphakeli wakho:

 

Imodeli ye-chip, hhayi nje "ikhadi le-IC."

Cela i-chip ethile: i-MIFARE Classic, i-MIFARE Plus, i-DESFire EV2, noma enye into. Uma umphakeli engakwazi ukucacisa, cishe bakhetha ukukhetha okushibhe kakhulu. Kwa-Syntek, yonke ikhotheshini ibala imodeli ye-chip enembile kanye nereferensi ye-NXP{3}}elandelekayo, ngoba sikudinga lokhu kubahlinzeki bethu be-chip ekhuphukayo ngaphambi kokwamukela izinto ezingenayo.

Ubunikazi bokuqalisa obubalulekile.

Ubani ohlela okhiye bokubethela, umkhiqizi noma wena? Uma amakhadi ehamba nokhiye abazenzakalelayo bengashintshiwe, amakhadi akho "abethelwe" asengozini njengamakhadi e-ID. Ukutholwa kwe-Fudan backdoor ka-2024 kubonise ukuthi ngisho nama-chips athengwe "njengaqinile" angakwazi ukuthwala ubungozi befekthri{2}}. Sibonile abathengi bethola amakhadi e-DESFire EV2 avela kwabanye abahlinzeki lapho yonke imikhakha isaphethe okhiye befekthri be-NXP, ngenxa yokuthi isistimu yesihlanganisi ayizange ikusekele ukunikezwa kokhiye wangokwezifiso. Kwadingeka bashintshe abathengisi futhi{6}baphinde bakhiphe ikhadi lakho konke ukusetshenziswa.

Ukuhambisana komfundi.

Qinisekisa ukuvama kwabafundi bakho abakhona kakade kanye nokusekelwa kwephrothokholi ngaphambi koku-oda. Ikhadi le-IC elingu-13.56 MHz elibhangqwe nesifundi esingu-125 kHz{3}kuphela liyi-paperweight ebizayo. Uma ungaqiniseki mayelana nezicaciso zakho zamanje zomfundi, i-Syntek ingakunikezawomabili amakhadi esampula e-ID ne-IC anemininingwane ye-chip ebhaliweukuze ukwazi ukuhlola ukuhambisana ngaphambi kokwenza i-oda lenqwaba.

Isinyathelo Esilandelayo

 

Ukukhetha phakathi kwe-IC namakhadi e-ID kuyisiqalo. Isinqumo sangempela ukuthi iyiphi i-chip, isiphi isigaba sezokuphepha, nokuthi iyiphi i-architecture elingana nendawo yakho ethile.

 

I-Syntek ikhiqiza amakhadi okufinyelela kusuka ku-EM4100 ngokusebenzisa amakhadi e-DESFire EV3 kanye ne-CPU, anomthamo wanyanga zonke wamakhadi angaphezu kwezigidi ezi-3. Uma uhlola ukusetshenziswa okusha noma uhlela ukufuduka kusuka ku-125 kHz,cela amasampula wamahhala anemininingwane egcwele ye-chip kwaSyntek RFIDukuhlola ngokumelene nabafundi bakho abakhona. Sitshele ukusethwa kwesistimu yakho yamanje futhi sizoncoma i-chip tier efana nezidingo zakho zokuphepha nesabelomali, hhayi nje inketho eshibhe kakhulu eshalofini.

Thumela ukuPhenya